Build a Papa John's order and we rank the restaurants we have priced by that basket’s pickup total. Example: A large pepperoni pizza and a 2-liter is $21.28 at a typical restaurant, and the cheapest of the 3,067 that sell the whole thing is $14.98 at 2235 W Everly Brothers Blvd, Cooper Creek Drive, Powderly, KY.
14 Inch Original Pepperoni Pizza, 2 Liter Pepsi, pickup, at 2235 W Everly Brothers Blvd, Cooper Creek Drive, Powderly, KY. That is the cheapest of 3,067 Papa John's restaurants that sell every item in this example. A typical one charges $21.28, which is $6.30 more than this restaurant. One cheap till is a fact; it is not the average.
As of 26 September 2026 · 3,088 restaurants priced · some prices date from 19 September 2026 because restaurants rotate through about weekly.
Your location stays in this browser. A ZIP or a city name works if you would rather not share it. Start from an example, or type an item from the priced menu — only real items can go in the basket.
The cheapest restaurant for the example order sits on the map. Type a real menu item, then search a ZIP or city — the pins follow the basket.
These totals are in the HTML on purpose. A search for “cheapest Papa John's near me” should not have to run JavaScript to see that a real restaurant, with a real address, charges a real number.
Typical restaurant: $21.28. 3,067 of 3,088 sell the whole order. Priced 24 September 2026. The next one, in 92 Madison Square Dr, Madisonville, KY, is $14.98, so this is not a one-restaurant freak.
Typical restaurant: $25.28. 3,067 of 3,088 sell the whole order. Priced 25 September 2026. The next one, in 1120 East Atlantic Street, La Crosse, VA, is $17.28, so this is not a one-restaurant freak.
Typical restaurant: $20.48. 3,039 of 3,088 sell the whole order. Priced 22 September 2026. The next one, in 855 Coshocton Ave, Mt Vernon, OH, is $15.48, so this is not a one-restaurant freak.
| Order | Cheapest restaurant we priced | There | Typical | Restaurants that sell it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A large pepperoni pizza and a 2-liter | 2235 W Everly Brothers Blvd, Cooper Creek Drive, Powderly, KY | $14.98 | $21.28 | 3,067 |
| A large pepperoni pizza and garlic knots | 3384 Highway 903, Macs Bracey, Convenience Store, Bracey, VA | $16.79 | $25.28 | 3,067 |
| Eight buffalo wings and cheesesticks | 621 N Main St, Canton, IL | $15.08 | $20.48 | 3,039 |
Build this order on the Papa John's menu, item by item →
The cheapest Papa John's on the brand index, which is a different question →
Every restaurant, not only the cheapest for this order, on the price map →
Other chains: cheapest restaurant for your order, across every chain we price.
Two restaurants of the same chain, item by item, is compare Papa John's restaurants — a different question from the cheapest till for one basket.
These are pickup prices, read from Papa John's own ordering system. Delivery, app-only promos, and combo discounts the till does not print as a line item are not in the total. Tax is not either: it depends on the city.
The list is the restaurants we have priced — 3,088 of them — not every Papa John's. A restaurant around the corner that we have not sampled will not appear, and we say so rather than inventing one. Restaurants rotate through about weekly, so some prices date from 19 September 2026 and some from 26 September 2026.
Items are matched by name after folding case, trademark marks, and punctuation. A size word is allowed to differ, so medium fries can stand in for fries; a Whopper Jr. is not treated as a Whopper. If a restaurant does not sell one of the items, it is listed as incomplete rather than ranked on a cheaper, smaller meal.