What Papa John's actually charges in New York — read from the chain's own ordering system at 93 New York restaurants, not from a national menu board.
Prices checked November 5, 2026 · 261 menu items priced in New York · Full menu: Papa John's menu prices
Across the whole Papa John's menu, New York pays 0.2% below the national typical price for the same items. Across all 10 chains, New York ranks #7 of 51 in our fast food prices by state index, paying 7.2% above the national typical price overall.
| Item | New York typical | US typical | Difference | Restaurants |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 Inch Original Pepperoni Pizza | $16.99 | $17.50 | -2.9% | 93 |
| 14 Inch Original Create Your Own | $16.99 | $17.49 | -2.9% | 93 |
| 14 Inch Thin Pepperoni Pizza | $16.99 | $17.50 | -2.9% | 93 |
| 14 Inch Original Sausage Pizza | $16.99 | $17.50 | -2.9% | 93 |
| 14 Inch Original Works Pizza | $19.49 | $20.99 | -7.1% | 93 |
| 14 Inch Original Meats Pizza | $19.49 | $20.99 | -7.1% | 93 |
| 14 Inch Thin Sausage Pizza | $16.99 | $17.50 | -2.9% | 93 |
| 14 Inch Thin Works Pizza | $19.49 | $20.99 | -7.1% | 93 |
Typical = median price across the restaurants in the right-hand column. The full Papa John's menu for a single restaurant is on the Papa John's menu prices page.
Named locations are the lowest and highest listed price for each item among New York restaurants in the checked collection, with till-glitch listings excluded (see methodology). Where several locations tie at the same extreme price, one is named and the tie is shown.
The typical price is $16.99, the median across the 93 Papa John's restaurants we price in New York (checked November 5, 2026). The cheapest is $13.99 at 148 State Route 37, Hogansburg; the priciest is $25.49 at 240 1St Street, Niagara Falls.
Across the whole Papa John's menu, New York pays 0.2% below the national typical price for the same items.
Our collection tracks prices at 93 Papa John's restaurants in New York, and 261 menu items are priced at three or more of them.
At the Papa John's on 148 State Route 37 in Hogansburg, at $13.99 — against a state typical price of $16.99.
We read the price of every item on the menu at each restaurant from the chain's own ordering system, every week. A "typical" price is the median across the restaurants named on the page, and every restaurant counts once: when a menu lists the same item twice under two spellings, the restaurant still contributes one price. The cheapest and priciest restaurants named on this page exclude the handful of listings whose price sits outside 0.4–2.5× the item's national typical price — a $99 sauce cup is a till glitch, not a price, and it should not be able to win "priciest" either. Named extremes also exclude one-day pricing anomalies: a price that appears at dozens of restaurants in a single day's collection and nowhere else in our archive is treated as a collection glitch, not a price, though those restaurants still count toward every typical price. State and city indexes average each menu item's local typical price against its national typical price, so every item counts once and no single chain dominates.